Strategic Planning to Guide Business Owners Through Change After the Connelly Case 

For business owners, attorneys, and financial advisors, the recent Connelly Case decision serves as a critical reminder of the complexities in business succession planning that business owners face. The case sheds light on how the IRS views business valuation and tax obligations, particularly when ownership transitions occur after a shareholder’s passing. 

Background on the Connelly Case 

The Connelly v. United States decision involved a dispute over the valuation of a deceased shareholder’s interest in a closely held business—Crown C Supply Company, co-owned by two brothers. The core issue revolved around how a life insurance-funded buy-sell agreement should impact estate tax valuation. 

In this case, the company held a life insurance policy on the deceased owner, with the stated purpose of using the proceeds to redeem his shares under a stock redemption (entity purchase) buy-sell agreement. However, the IRS took issue with how the company’s value was calculated for estate tax purposes. 

The technique used—a redemption-style buy-sell agreement funded by life insurance—excluded the life insurance proceeds from the company’s value, arguing that they were offset by the obligation to purchase the deceased’s shares. 

But the IRS disagreed. The court ultimately ruled that: 

The life insurance proceeds increased the value of the company, even if intended for redemption. 

The buy-sell agreement was not binding for valuation purposes under IRC §2703, largely because it did not meet all the required elements (e.g., it wasn’t a bona fide business arrangement or comparable to arms-length transactions). 

As a result, the estate had to include the full fair market value of the deceased’s ownership interest—including the insurance proceeds—leading to a significant estate tax liability. 

Key Implications for Your Business Owner Clients  

The Connelly decision highlights the importance of well-structured buy-sell agreements and the need for careful tax planning. Here’s what business owners, attorneys, and advisors should be proactively planning for: 

Buy-Sell Agreements Must Reflect Reality 

  • Agreements that undervalue shares or lack clear valuation formulas may be challenged. 
  • The IRS may disregard agreements if they don’t meet fair market valuation principles. 

Tax Liabilities Can Be Significant 

  • Surviving owners may face increased tax burdens if business valuation disputes arise. 
  • Proper structuring and funding mechanisms (e.g. life insurance) can help mitigate these risks. 

Attorneys Must Draft Defensible Agreements 

  • Legal professionals should ensure that buy-sell agreements comply with IRS standards and state laws. 
  • Proper documentation and valuation methodologies will be critical to avoiding disputes. 

Estate and Succession Planning Requires Proactive Review 

  • Business owners should regularly update agreements to reflect current value and IRS standards. 
  • Attorneys and advisors should collaborate to stress-test planning strategies. 

What Should Attorneys and Advisors Do Now? 

The Connelly decision highlights the need to collaborate proactively, ensuring business owners’ succession plans are both legally sound and financially efficient. Collaborative Insurance Solutions (CIS) can provide additional expertise and resources to navigate complex tax and valuation issues. 

✔ Review and Update Buy-Sell Agreements – Attorneys should ensure agreements contain clear, defensible valuation methodologies that align with IRS guidelines, while advisors assess the financial implications for clients. 

✔ Leverage Life Insurance for Funding – CIS professionals can assist in structuring life insurance solutions that provide liquidity for ownership transitions, reducing financial strain on businesses and estates. 

✔ Coordinate Legal, Financial, and Insurance Expertise – Attorneys, tax professionals, and CIS specialists should work together to create succession strategies that minimize tax burdens and align with business objectives. Establishing a collaborative approach ensures that legal agreements, funding mechanisms, and financial planning strategies work in tandem to protect business owners and their heirs. 

It’s our responsibility to support clients. By partnering with trusted advisors, attorneys, and experts, we can help business owners navigate the ever-changing regulatory landscape, mitigate risks, and craft succession plans that protect and preserve their wealth.  

Final Thoughts 

Without proper planning, business transitions can quickly become legal and financial nightmares. By taking a proactive approach to succession planning, business owners can protect their legacy, reduce tax burdens, and ensure a smooth transition. 

For attorneys, this case reinforces the need for meticulous drafting of agreements to withstand IRS scrutiny. Ensuring compliance now can prevent costly disputes later. 

If you’re unsure how this decision might impact your business or practice, now is the time to review your agreements, consult with trusted experts, and take proactive steps to protect the interests of your clients.  

Want to explore what this could look like? Contact CIS today.

Save the Date: CE on Strategic Solutions for Business Owner Clients After Connelly  

Join us for a deep dive into the Connelly case and its implications for business succession planning. Save the date for June 12 at 2 PM to gain expert insights and actionable strategies. 

 

About the Author: Eryka Morehead is the dynamic Founder and CEO of Collaborative Insurance Solutions. With nearly two decades of experience in the financial services industry, Eryka has established herself as a leading insurance strategist, known for her ability to simplify complex information and deliver impactful solutions for her clients.

 

 

—

Collaborative Insurance Solutions does not provide tax, legal, or accounting advice. This material has been prepared for informational purposes only and should not be relied on for tax, legal, or accounting guidance. Please consult your own tax, legal, and accounting advisors before engaging in any transaction.